← The CRBA guide

Two documents, two different jobs

The most common CRBA misunderstanding is thinking one document replaces the other. It doesn't — and knowing which does what saves you a repeat embassy trip.

The CRBA proves your child's US citizenship. The Malaysian birth certificate proves the birth itself. You will need both, for different doors, for the rest of their life.

The State Department says it plainly: the FS-240 is not a birth certificate, even though it carries the birth facts. And no US state will ever issue a birth certificate for a foreign birth — the JPN document is it, permanently.

Checked against travel.state.gov and USCIS guidance — July 2026
The document trio

What each one proves

DocumentWhat it provesWhere it comes from
Malaysian birth certificateThe civil facts — when, where, and to whom the child was born, with recorded parentage.JPN, after registering the birth within 60 days. Certified extracts available later for RM5.
CRBA (FS-240)US citizenship acquired at birth — same legal force as a Certificate of Citizenship. Never expires. Not a travel document.The State Department, via a US embassy, before the child turns 18.
Certificate of Citizenship (N-600)Alternative USCIS-issued citizenship evidence — it also covers citizenship derived after birth. Optional redundancy for most CRBA holders.USCIS, by application and fee — Form N-600.
Which one, when

The situations that actually come up

SituationBringThe nuance
US passport applicationCRBA (+ birth cert for a child)The CRBA proves citizenship; the birth certificate can be required to prove the parent-child relationship.
REAL ID / driver's licenseCRBAFederally acceptable — but state DMVs add presentation rules (originals or certified copies, plus identity documents). Check your state's list.
Social Security numberBothSSA wants citizenship evidence (CRBA or passport) plus age and identity evidence (the birth certificate).
School enrollmentEither, usuallySchools want age and identity; both documents carry the birth facts. Some districts specifically ask for the birth certificate.
Proving parentage or custodyBirth certificateThe CRBA doesn't establish custody or replace civil parentage records.
Federal jobs, benefits, later citizenship paperworkCRBAIt's lifetime proof of citizenship — the reason the original lives in the fireproof folder, and a spare certified copy is worth US$50.

Lost either one? The CRBA replacement runs through Form DS-5542; a Malaysian birth-register extract comes from JPN for RM5. Neither loss affects the citizenship or the birth facts — only the paperwork.

Common questions

Document questions, answered plainly

Is a CRBA the same as a birth certificate?
No. The CRBA (FS-240) is proof of US citizenship — for that job it has the same legal force as a Certificate of Citizenship. The foreign birth certificate is the civil record of the birth itself: when, where, and to whom. Different jobs, both permanent.
Does a CRBA work for REAL ID?
Federal REAL ID rules list the FS-240 as acceptable evidence of citizenship. In practice, state DMVs add their own presentation rules — Texas, for example, wants an original or certified copy, and states may ask for extra identity documents alongside it. Check your state's document checklist before the appointment.
Which document does my child use to get a US passport?
The CRBA proves citizenship for the passport application. For a child's passport the State Department may still ask for the foreign birth certificate too, because it's the document that proves the parent-child relationship.
Do we need a US state birth certificate for a child born abroad?
No such thing exists for a foreign birth — no US state will issue one. The Malaysian certificate from JPN is the birth certificate, permanently. That's why you guard the original and order a certified extract if you ever need a spare.
Does a child with a CRBA ever need a Certificate of Citizenship (N-600)?
Usually not. USCIS itself says a person who already holds valid citizenship evidence doesn't need an N-600. Some families file one anyway for an independent USCIS record — that's optional redundancy, weighed against the fee and processing time.
What about school enrollment and Social Security?
Schools generally want proof of age and identity — the birth certificate does that; the CRBA also carries the birth facts and is widely accepted. For the Social Security number, SSA wants citizenship evidence (CRBA or US passport) plus age/identity evidence (the Malaysian birth certificate) — another reason both documents stay in the same fireproof folder.

Still need to get the CRBA in the first place? Eligibility, the KL sequence, the document folder, and the four clocks — all in the main guide.

Read the CRBA guide →